Endearist
DE EN Get Endearist

Question set · Best friend

30 Hypothetical Questions to Ask Your Best Friend

30 hypothetical questions for your best friend — would-you-rather and what-if scenarios that turn a normal night into one you both remember.

By Endearist 30 questions

You already know your best friend's history. What a good what-if does is show you how they decide — who they'd save, what they'd risk, which version of a good life they'd actually pick. These thirty range from the gleefully stupid to the quietly revealing, because the best nights with a best friend swing between both without warning.

Warm-up questions

  1. If we could teleport anywhere for dinner tonight, where are we eating? Easy and fun. Watch whether she picks a place or a person to eat with.
  2. Would you rather never be cold again or never be hot again? A real divide, and oddly heated. Make her commit before she negotiates.
  3. If you had to keep one app on your phone and delete all the rest, which survives?
  4. Would you rather be able to fly or be invisible — and what would you actually use it for? The use case is the tell. Invisible-for-mischief and fly-to-escape are different people.
  5. If our lives were a movie, which actor plays you and who's the comic relief — me?
  6. Would you rather always know when someone's lying or always get away with lying yourself? Which power she grabs says a lot about what she's afraid of.
  7. If you woke up with one new skill mastered overnight, what is it?
  8. Would you rather fight one horse-sized duck or a hundred duck-sized horses? Pure nonsense, and a genuine test of how someone reasons under absurdity.
  9. If you could swap lives with me for one day, what's the first thing you'd do? Funny on the surface, but listen for what she envies or pities in your life.
  10. If we won the lottery together tomorrow, what's the dumbest thing we buy first?

Going deeper

  1. If you could relive one year of your life knowing what you know now, which year? Whether she picks a good year to enjoy or a bad one to fix is the whole answer.
  2. If you had to give up your job or your home city, which goes? Whether she's rooted in work or place tells you where her identity sits.
  3. If a stranger handed you a one-way ticket to start over with no contacts, do you take it? The pause before she answers tells you how settled she actually feels.
  4. If you could read one person's true opinion of you, whose would you pick?
  5. Would you rather have your dream career or your dream relationship, if you couldn't have both? An old question, but the way she ranks them now may surprise you both.
  6. If you could erase one memory of yours forever, would you, and why that one?
  7. If you had to live in another decade for the rest of your life, which one? Nostalgia for an era she never lived in usually points at something she's missing.
  8. If you could guarantee one outcome in your life by giving up choice in everything else, would you?
  9. If we could send a message to ourselves at fifteen, what does yours say? Light frame, real weight. What she'd warn herself about is what still stings.
  10. If you had to be famous for one thing, would you rather be loved by few or known by millions?

The vulnerable ones

  1. If you could know the exact day you'll die, would you want to? The forced yes/no is the point. Make her answer before she qualifies it.
  2. If you could undo one decision and accept you'd lose everything that came after it, would you? The 'everything after' clause is what makes this brutal and honest.
  3. If you had to choose between a long ordinary life and a short remarkable one, which? An ancient question, but her answer now reveals what she's quietly afraid of wasting.
  4. If I were in real trouble and helping me cost you something big, where's your limit? Risky and worth it. The honest limit means more than a heroic exaggeration.
  5. If you could feel exactly how someone you've hurt felt, would you choose to?
  6. If you had to confess your worst trait out loud and live with it being known, what is it? Go first here. She won't name hers until you've named yours.
  7. If your life ended tomorrow, what would you most regret never having said to someone? If the unsaid thing is fixable, this question is secretly a nudge to go fix it.
  8. If you could be certain of one belief — God, fate, none of it — which would you want settled? Which uncertainty she'd most want resolved reveals what quietly unsettles her.
  9. If you had to pick the moment your life peaks, is it behind you, now, or still coming?
  10. If we were old women on a porch, what do you hope we're still doing together? End here. It quietly turns every what-if back into the real friendship under it.

What to do with the answers

The most honest answer you'll get tonight is gone in three months unless you write it down. Endearist keeps it — per person, end-to-end encrypted, with a cadence reminder so you can pick the thread back up next time without scrolling through your messages.

More questions for your best friend

More questions about hypotheticals

Related tools

Frequently asked

Aren't hypotheticals just a silly party game?

The silly ones are, and that's their job — they lower the guard. But a forced choice reveals values that a direct question would make someone perform. Asking 'what do you value?' gets a polished answer; asking 'save the stranger or the photo album?' gets the real one. The game is the disguise; the decision underneath is what you actually learn.

My friend always answers 'both' or refuses to choose. How do I handle that?

Close the exit before you ask: 'no fence-sitting, you have to pick one and tell me why.' If she still dodges, add a tiny cost to neutral — 'you lose both if you won't choose' — and she'll commit. The refusal to choose is itself revealing, but the defended choice is what makes the night worth having.

How do I move from the funny ones to the deep ones without it getting weird?

Follow the order — the list is built to slide, not jump. Let the duck question earn its laugh, then drift one notch heavier each round. If a deep one lands flat, bounce back up to a silly one; depth between friends isn't a staircase you climb once, it's a tide you let come in and go out. Trust the rhythm over a checklist.

Is it cheating to think about my own answer before I ask?

It's the opposite — it's the whole etiquette. These only work as trades, so know your own answer and be willing to go first, especially on the heavier ones. A friend who interrogates without offering anything turns a game into a deposition. The fastest way to get an honest answer is to have just given one yourself.

Some of her answers surprised me. Worth holding onto?

Absolutely — a surprising answer is a door into a part of your friend you hadn't met, and it's the perfect thing to circle back to weeks later: 'you said you'd take the one-way ticket — still true?' Endearist's private, encrypted per-person notebook is built to hold exactly these, so the offhand reveal becomes the start of the next real conversation instead of a thing you both forget.